A Szu-57-be szerelt rendszer az vajon milyen? Hát a Gorskov-osztályba szerelt radar?
Miért kiabálsz?
A Felonnak és a Gorskovnak is AESA radarja van (a fregattnak nem csak az van, de amire te gondolsz, az AESA), de ezek GaAs technológiájú radarok.
GaN vs GaAs:
"
Technical Comparison: GAA vs GaN Radar
Power Handling and Efficiency
The most significant difference between GAA and GaN radar technologies lies in their power handling capabilities and efficiency characteristics. GaN radar systems can handle significantly higher power densities, typically 5-10 times greater than GaAs systems. This advantage stems from GaN’s superior thermal conductivity and higher breakdown voltage.
GaN radar efficiency typically ranges from 50-65%, while GaAs systems generally achieve 25-40% efficiency. This efficiency difference has profound implications for system design, power consumption, and thermal management. Higher efficiency translates directly into reduced
power supply requirements, simplified cooling systems, and improved system reliability.
The power advantage of GaN becomes particularly pronounced at higher frequencies. While both technologies can operate at millimeter-wave frequencies, GaN maintains its power and efficiency advantages even as frequency increases, making it the preferred choice for high-frequency, high-power applications.
Frequency Response and Bandwidth
Both GAA and GaN radar technologies offer excellent frequency response characteristics, but with different strengths. GaN radar systems maintain consistent performance across broader frequency ranges, making them suitable for wideband and multi-band applications. The technology’s inherent characteristics enable operation from L-band through Ka-band and beyond with minimal performance degradation.
GaAs radar systems traditionally excel in specific frequency bands where their noise performance advantages are most pronounced. The technology is particularly effective in applications requiring exceptional sensitivity and low-noise operation, even if maximum power output is not the primary concern.
The bandwidth capabilities of both technologies are sufficient for modern radar applications, including pulse compression, frequency agility, and spread spectrum techniques. However, GaN’s broader operating bandwidth provides greater flexibility for multi-function radar systems and software-defined radio applications.
Thermal Performance and Reliability
Thermal management represents a critical differentiator between GAA and GaN radar technologies. GaN’s superior thermal conductivity (approximately 1.3 W/cm·K) compared to GaAs (0.46 W/cm·K) enables better
heat dissipation and improved thermal performance. This characteristic is crucial for high-power radar applications where thermal management directly impacts system reliability and performance.
GaN radar systems can operate at higher junction temperatures while maintaining stable performance, reducing cooling requirements and enabling more compact system designs. The improved thermal performance also contributes to longer component lifetimes and enhanced system reliability.
The reliability characteristics of both technologies are excellent when properly designed and implemented. However, GaN’s ability to operate at higher temperatures and power levels while maintaining performance provides additional margin for robust system operation in challenging environments.
Cost analysis between GAA and GaN radar technologies involves multiple factors beyond initial component prices. While GaAs components are generally less expensive per unit, the total system cost comparison must consider performance capabilities, power consumption, cooling requirements, and system complexity.
GaN radar systems, despite higher initial component costs, often provide better value in high-performance applications due to their superior efficiency and power handling capabilities. The reduced power consumption and simplified cooling requirements can offset higher component costs in many applications.
The cost differential between technologies continues to narrow as GaN manufacturing volumes increase and processes mature. For many applications, the performance advantages of GaN justify any cost premium, particularly when total cost of ownership is considered."
Introduction to Advanced Radar Technologies The radar technology landscape has undergone significant transformation in recent years, with two prominent technologies leading the charge: Gallium Arsenide (GaAs) and Gallium Nitride (GaN) radar systems. Understanding the fundamental differences...
www.raypcb.com
